Report from Tech Radar
In Brief – Utah has begun enforcing age-verification requirements on adult websites, while its novel provision targeting VPNs remains blocked by a federal court. The law, SB 73, requires commercial websites hosting a substantial portion of material deemed harmful to minors to use “reasonable” methods to verify visitors are at least 18. Violations carry fines of up to $2,500, while a 2% excise tax on covered sites has applied since October 1. However, the state cannot enforce a provision that treats people physically in the state as Utah users even when they are masking their locations through VPNs or proxies and prohibits covered sites from discussing VPN use. Adult site owner Aylo challenged the provision as imposing an excessive burden on the out-of-state company and violating the First Amendment, and District Judge David Barlow issued a preliminary injunction in September, finding that the provision is “likely unconstitutional”. Users with Utah IP addresses will now likely face ID checks or facial scans through third-party providers. Aylo objects to imposing site-level user identification, arguing it is largely ineffective and threatens privacy, and has blocked Utah users since 2023.
Context – The explosion of age-based online content laws is drawing attention to how users often try to employ VPN technology services to circumvent local online content restrictions. Governments around the world are enacting various age limits and regulations to restrict teens from social media, pornography and gaming sites. VPN usage reportedly spiked in the UK a year ago as users responded to age checks inspired by their Online Safety Act, and in Australia when their 16-year-old social media age limit went into effect. Officials in the UK, France, and several US states are calling for legal restrictions on VPNs to stymie their use as an online regulation work-around. VPN use is also at the heart of global content takedown orders X received from an Australian regulator and Canadian judge, both ruling that since local users could employ a VPN to circumvent a local online content restriction, X needed to block offending content globally.
