Report from the Wall Street Journal
In Brief – The European Commission has issued preliminary findings that TikTok’s “For You” feed violates the Digital Services Act (DSA) by repeatedly exposing users to harmful and triggering content. The regulators call it a “rabbit-hole effect” and say the platform should change its recommendation feed, including disabling viewing time as an indicator its algorithm uses to recommend more similar content. Commissioner Henna Virkkunen, the bloc’s tech chief, said repeated scrolling and liking videos prompts the algorithm to serve more similar content, potentially trapping users in content loops they cannot easily escape. TikTok disputed some of the commission findings, saying they inaccurately characterize its platform architecture and misrepresent its record of protecting users and providing content controls.
Context – Social media critics have long argued that the platforms are dangerous and harmful. To deflect charges that they are trying to censor disfavored speech, critics have primarily targeted “addictive” design features like auto-play and “likes”, supposedly regardless of the underlying content. This is especially critical in the US context because of the First Amendment and Sec. 230, but anti-social media efforts are global, so they are part of campaigns elsewhere as well. The EU Commission has already made preliminary findings that TikTok, Facebook and Instagram have addictive features that may violate the DSA. Regulating the algorithms behind “feeds” is basically an offshoot of this broader theme. In Australia, the Government’s digital duty of care legislation includes a requirement that platforms give users the option of a chronological feed, which they dub the “My Feed, My Way” initiative. Who doesn’t want millions of pieces of content ordered just by when they were posted that day? Apple recently criticized the Commission’s plan telling Google exactly how to open the Android operating system to third-party AI under the Digital Markets Act, saying “The EC is redesigning an OS. It is substituting judgments made by Google’s engineers for its own judgment based on less than three months of work.” They are redesigning social media platforms too.
