Report from Courthouse News
In Brief – A California appeals court has affirmed the dismissal of lawsuits by four school districts seeking to hold Meta, Google, TikTok and Snap liable for contributing to a student mental health crisis. The districts argued that social media addiction disrupted their educational missions and forced them to spend staff time and money addressing student depression, anxiety, eating disorders and self-harm. More than 1,000 school districts filed lawsuits in both federal court and California state court against the companies, as did thousands of teenagers alleging similar harms. The school districts’ state law cases were dismissed in 2024 after Judge Carolyn Kuhl found insufficient grounds for negligence or public nuisance claims. A unanimous three-judge appellate panel has now agreed. Judge Kuhl allowed the teenagers’ cases to proceed, and the first bellwether trial resulted in a jury finding Meta and Google liable and awarding a teen $6 million in damages. School district claims in federal court are proceeding as well, and the platforms settled the first bellwether school trial for $27 million.
Context – Sec. 230, which protects digital platforms from liability for harm caused by content created by their users, has pushed social media critics to pursue civil litigation and state legislation alleging that the platforms were designed to addict young users and led to significant mental health harm. Thousands of private plaintiffs and State AGs have filed complaints. The cases have largely been consolidated in the California state court of Judge Kuhl and the federal court of Judge Yvonne Gonzalez-Rogers. While Kuhl dismissed the school district lawsuits Judge Gonzalez allowed the school districts’ federal lawsuits to proceed. Along with the initial school district settlement, the platforms have settled with two additional teen bellwether plaintiffs, and Meta reached a massive settlement agreement with 48 states that includes big policy changes and up to $18 billion in payments over a decade. Enough losses may lead all the platforms to agree to make changes that might not withstand First Amendment scrutiny if they were legislated.
