bbieron@platformeconomyinsights.com

Judge Tersely Rejects Apple Efforts to Join the Google Search Antitrust Case

Feb 12, 2025

Report from The Verge

In Brief – US District Court Judge Amit Mehta has summarily denied Apple’s emergency request to stay his recent decision rejecting their effort to halt the Google Search monopoly trial and join the litigation directly to protect their interests, in particular the highly lucrative agreement Google has had to be the default search provider on Apple devices. Last August, Mehta sided with the US Department of Justice (DoJ) and ruled that Google held a monopoly in the market for general internet search and engaged in illegal conduct to maintain that search monopoly, especially through large payments to Apple and Samsung to make its search engine the default option on smartphones and browsers. Judge Mehta will determine Google’s penalties and corrective actions this year, with the in-court portion of the trial’s remedies phase set for April. Last fall, the DoJ asked for very aggressive conduct remedies including forcing Google to spin off its Chrome browser, modify Android, restrict AI efforts, and allow competitors to access Google’s search data. Google called it a “wildly overbroad proposal” that went “miles beyond the Court’s decision” and submitted an offer that would prohibit it from engaging in the conduct Mehta ruled illegally protected Google search from potential competitors. Apple then requested to join the litigation claiming that Google was not likely to defend the contract relationships that pay Apple almost $20 billion a year.

Context – If Judge Mehta accepts even some parts of the DoJ remedy it would be the most aggressive US effort to rein in a tech giant since the DoJ attempt to break up Microsoft in 2000. It would be even more striking given his relatively narrow findings of illegality and harm. The aggressive Biden antitrust enforcers have moved on but some high-profile officials in the new administration have been very critical of Google in the past. President Trump has often complained that Google search treats him unfairly but has also said breaking up big US companies like Google might be a bad idea. Finally, Judge Mehta certainly knows that Judge Thomas Penfield Jackson’s order breaking up Microsoft in 2000 was overturned on appeal.

View By Monthly
Latest Blog
Snap Settles Latest Social Media Addiction Teen Bellwether Lawsuit

Report from The Hill In Brief – Snapchat has settled claims from two teen plaintiffs alleging that the platform was intentionally designed to be addictive to young users, ending a high-profile Los Angeles trial two days before opening arguments. The plaintiffs, from...

EU Commission Wants Frontex to Monitor Online Immigration Content

Report from The Next Web In Brief – The European Commission has proposed giving Frontex, the EU’s border agency, authority to monitor social media posts about migration and flag problematic content. The proposal, included in a broader Frontex overhaul, would establish...

DC Attorney General Joins Thirteen States Suing TikTok Over Safety

Report from Fox 5 In Brief – The District of Columbia has joined the litigation efforts of 13 states suing TikTok, accusing the social media platform of harming children through intentionally addictive design, deceptive claims about user safety, and other violations...

Social Media Giants Lose Challenge Against Ofcom Information Demands

Report from Courthouse News In Brief – The High Court in London has rejected legal challenges by Meta, TikTok and X against demands from Britain’s online safety regulator, Ofcom, for information about how the platforms moderate harmful content. The ruling backs the...

Platform Economy Insights produces a short email four times a week that reviews two top stories with concise analysis. It is the best way to keep on top of the news you should know. Sign up for this free email here.

* indicates required