Report from Politico
In Brief – Meta, Google and TikTok have each filed a federal lawsuit challenging California’s online safety law, AB 1709, which restricts access to allegedly “addictive” features of social media platforms such as infinite scrolling and autoplay for users under 16. The companies argue the law violates the First Amendment by interfering with their editorial decisions about how content is curated, ranked and displayed. Their complaints rely heavily on a 2024 Supreme Court ruling recognizing platforms’ constitutional rights to design algorithms governing content moderation and presentation. Meta also argues that the law is preempted by Sec. 230 of the Communications Decency Act because it effectively imposes liability for how platforms organize third-party content. All three lawsuits seek declarations that the law is unconstitutional and an injunction preventing Attorney General Rob Bonta from enforcing it. Bonta’s office said it would defend the law and the legislation’s author criticized the companies for suing.
Context – Social media critics have argued for years that the platforms are dangerous and harmful, especially for teens. Despite mixed evidence, age-based restrictions are taking off around the world. In the US, regulating social media faces legal hurdles in Sec. 230 and the First Amendment. In response, critics pursued legislation and civil litigation targeting “addictive” platform features supposedly regardless of the underlying content. As states began passing laws with age-based regulations, most were initially blocked by federal judges applying “strict” First Amendment reviews. However, soon after the Supreme Court ruled in 2025 that age checks for porn sites should be judged under “intermediate scrutiny”, appeals courts have delivered conflicting verdicts on social media laws, upholding some. In the first case that reached the Supreme Court on an emergency appeal, which was turned down, Justice Kavanaugh issued a concurring opinion summarizing the court precedents on the free-speech rights of young people and why he thought Mississippi’s law would eventually be struck down. The issue seems destined for the High Court.
